J Hotel & Resorts owner MP Abdulla Jabir has responded to no payment allegations made by Aldihoo Resort staff, declaring “If they do not like it, they can leave”.
Staff at the resort revealed how both Maldivian and foreign workers had not received pay for four months and six months respectively, despite complaints made to management and various external government organisations.
Alidhoo Resort in Haa Alif Atoll is run by J Hotel & Resorts, a company owned by Maldivian Democratic Party (MDP) MP Abdullah Jabir, the husband of former Human Rights Minister Dhiyana Saeed.
Five Alidhoo Resort workers living in the near-by island of Dhidhdhoo spoke to Minivan News – under condition of anonymity – of their frustration as management continues to withhold their pay.
The five workers claim that the Human Rights Commission of Maldives (HRCM) has “forgotten” about them, despite multiple complaints made to the institution.
“We [staff] complain every other week to the HRCM, but never receive any response. We contacted the Labour Ministry and they told us they would reply in November, but they still haven’t got back to us.
“Our verbal complaints never get us anywhere with management, usually they say ‘we can’t pay you right now”’even though the resort’s been at 100 percent occupancy the last few months,” alleged the staff.
Earlier this year the Tourism Employees’ Association of the Maldives (TEAM) released information revealing that Alidhoo’s management had not paid the resort’s 125 expatriate staff for six months, while the 85 local employees had not been paid since May.
“I am struggling more than the staff”: MP Abdulla Jabir
Responding to the no payment allegations, J Hotel & Resorts Chairman Abdulla Jabir explained that there was a delay in payment because of a “delay in making money”.
Jabir claimed that there had been less than 30 percent occupancy in the last year, despite staff claiming it being at 100 percent for the last two months.
“We have 250 staff [at Alidhoo Resort] and rather than go on leave and then come back during times of low occupancy they are telling us they want to stay.
“[The staff] are not struggling, that’s wrong. If they are struggling, they will not stay. They are staying and that means they are not struggling.
“I am struggling more than them,” he added.
Staff have gone on strike on three previous occasions over the salary issue, but have been met with harsh penalties including the dismissal of those staff involved in the strikes.
Sources from within the resort claim they face losing their jobs if they make a formal complaint to management and are therefore “trapped” over the payment issue.
Despite Jabir’s company owning Alidhoo Resort, the MDP MP distanced himself from allegations made by the workers claiming that he “is not involved in this” and that the media need to contact the people responsible for the matter, adding: “You don’t contact [Silvio] Berlusconi for every matter in Italy, you contact the respective ministers.”
“If I close the resort they don’t get pay, they don’t get food, they don’t get accommodation and they will be jobless.
“Maybe they get 10 days, 15 days delay in salary, or even a month’s delay in salary, but they are making it. It is not an issue,” Jabir told Minivan News.
“The staff can go home if they feel like not working for us.”
A mother from Baarah, Haa Alif Atoll who has worked at the Alidhoo Resort for the last four years, alleged to Minivan News that even when staff are paid late, they are rarely paid the full amount.
“In two months they will pay for just one month, and if pay is delayed for three months, we will still only get one month’s pay, that is how they operate,” she said.
“I went to Human Resources and asked why my salary has been cut off for the last four months and they said ‘we can only pay for one month’, and that’s MVR 3000 (US$ 195).”
Jabir has agreed to sell property to finance staff: Jabir’s wife Dhiyana Saeed
When the staff payment issue was raised back in June 2012, the now former Human Rights Minister Dhiyana Saeed – who is also the wife of J Hotel & Resorts chairman – said that no complaints had been made to her ministry.
Speaking to Minivan News over the recent claims, Dhiyana said that she was aware that her husband was having financial “trouble” and that there are outstanding payments to both staff and other people, however she claimed that Jabir is “doing his best” to repay the debts.
“We talk about these problems at home and [Jabir] has agreed to sell his property to finance staff and other people.
“It has been very hard for him to raise the money, but we are very close to making a deal with selling the property and clearing our debts,” said Dhiyana.
MDP members mark International Human Rights Day
Jabir, who recently switched from the Jumhoree Party (JP) to the Maldivian Democratic Party (MDP), joined the MDP’s Journey of Pledges tour as they visited neighbouring islands to Alidhoo Resort.
Minivan News raised the staff payment issue with MDP President Mohamed Nasheed moments after he had just completed a run to mark International Human Rights Day in Kulhudufushi earlier this week.
“There has been so many human trafficking allegations and you mention a certain entrepreneur having not paid [his staff], but I keep on going to work sites all over the country and there are so many ex-pats unpaid and their working conditions are also so bad, that is human trafficking,” said Nasheed. “If you have appropriate standards across the board then you won’t have this opportunity of cheap labour.”
HRCM’s Investigation Officer Aishaph Afreen Mohamed revealed that a complaint had been lodged by Alidhoo Resort staff in September, and that an investigation by the HRCM into the complaint is “ongoing”.
When asked how long the investigation is expected to last, Aishaph stated she was “not sure” as the HRCM has to obtain information “from all relevant departments”.
Almost all staff have now been paid: Alidhoo GM Jadhulla Jaleel
General Manager of the Alidhoo Resort Jadhulla Jaleel, admitted there had been a delay in paying staff, but claimed that as of today “almost all” staff had been paid.
“Sometimes there is a delay, but we always pay. Our staff trust us that they will be paid,” Jaleel said. “Only today (November 11) we have paid almost all of the staff, we paid a total of MVR 500,000.”
When asked to further clarify how many staff come under “almost all”, Jaleel then stated: “All staff, both foreign and local have been paid.
“If you call your sources, they will confirm they have been paid. Some of the staff won’t be able to confirm it because they won’t have collected their money today,” Jaleel claimed.
A reliable source within the resort confirmed to Minivan News that as of November 11 they had been paid, but for only two out of the four months owed. The source also alleged that foreign staff members were yet to receive any of their six-months of missing payments.
(0)Dislikes
(0)Related Posts
Majlis accepts bill to criminalise tourism boycotts- Further protests as MDP calls for international community to be “mindful” of Maldives judiciary
- “We have been off the streets for some time – now we are back”: MDP
- HRCM findings will reflect CNI conclusions on transfer of power: President’s Office
- Pro-government MPs hit out at UN’s “biased” and “political” calls for religious freedom
- Maldives judiciary hammered in UN human rights review
JaBeer is probably the best Beer in the world.
Jabir deservers what he gets. He's been switching political alliances to save his arse, essentially. Looks like the pyramid is beginning to tumble upon him.
There are many companies with delayed payments to both local and foreign staff. So I wonder why you only talk about one company. Is it because Jabir is in parliament?
This story tells me that you can feed a thousand people but fail to feed one and that one failure will make people forget the one thousand you fed. I'm not a fan of jabir's political swinging but it is still a fact that he started from scratch and built a company that provided employment for many people. He may be in financial trouble today but before we quicken to badmouth him, we should remember the thousands of jobs he provided over the years, the income that provided to those families. That also must count to something.
Most companies go through tough times at one point or the other. Give the man space to recover. The country loses nothing and gains much when it helps an entrepreneur to stay afloat because it then saves jobs and other ancillary income generating activities.
I'm surprised that minivan news does not draw a distinction between yacht tours, and Jabir. They are two separate legal entities and Jabir is just one shareholder. There are other shareholders in the company and you have slagged off the politicians who are associated with that company but you have not sought a comment from the other shareholders.
I work for the same company and have been there for years. The company has paid for my studies abroad and has paid us for years even through deed losses in recent times. This ought to be told too, if you are writing about one area of it's loss.
If there is ever a political parody show in Maldives..
Firstly I must thank Mr. Powell for writing this. I read it and actually pinched myself to confirm that I am reading this from Minivannews - which brands itself as an advocate of human rights yet, leans towards MDP.
So many levels of parody here. Jabir being an MP who does pay his staff (and technically in debt), his wife being a former Minister who agrees he in debt, HRC ignoring employee complaints, comment about Belousconi, President Nasheeds weighing in on the matter, employees saying that they are not paid, management saying they are paid. Later the author mentioning that they are paid for 2 months out of 4.
What a comedy Mr. Powel. If employees are are not paid in FULL, they are not paid. No second way about it. Its like saying your wife is half pregnant.
Dont vilify handpicked people, there are many business in male and many more resorts that dont pay salary in time.
lack of research and lazy minivan team
Jabir may sell all his properties but please tell him not to sell Diyana
How many beds property Is Dhiyana? Which resort.
Oh Man!! You have been on a "trip" these few months..well..at least from the time Berlusconi resigned as Italy's PM
"Ali..u were saying.." THE FACT IS THAT US$ 2 MILLION OF PUBLIC FUNDS (via STO)WAS SCRATCHED OUT OF OUR COFFERS TO help jumpstart "YACHT TOURS"....
Did Minivan forget the MP Abdulla 'loly' Jabir is MDP man?
What is the point of owning several resorts and claiming you are one of the richest people in MALDIVES when you can't pay salary to your own staff. Jabir maybe very good at cutting business deals and juggling multiple resort developments, but I have yet to see him being able to properly manage one. This does put his capacity as a true businessman and entrepreneur into question. Perhaps his "ministers" need to be replaced by more competent and capable people who can keep Jabir flamboyant behavior and rapid decisions on the leash
lol.
@John
You wish :p
Jon Stewart said: "If there is ever a political parody show in Maldives.."
That will never happen, that is freedom of speech and this is the Maldives 🙁
This is the difference between third grade fishermen and foreign investors. The Maldivian are so backward and don’t do anything in civilized way. This issue of cheap business is not only with Jabir.
If you look at all the Maldivian business people, they are the same. They think the employees are their slaves and behave like the money they have is excreted from their*****. They are so ignorant that they don’t know the money they make has equal share of struggle and effort by those who work for them. And simply forget that their first priority is to pay for those who fuel their business. If these guys can’t pay to workers they can’t simply ask the employees to leave but rather shutdown their business, like normal people would do, it is like if you can’t buy tools to do your job you just simply stop doing what you planed to do,
The famous business, people Deen, Koli, Buruma all behave in the same way and if you listen to those guys, they sound that the employee are at their mercy. Buruma would say, this is money I have worked hard to get this my money and you people are shit eating my money, Deen would say, I have done this and that for you and you are simply unthankful for my mercy. Koli would smell his finger after scratching his ass and would say, you “nagoo balhu “Bastard, when he gets fit when he meets his employees. These are the mental capacity and educational level of Maldivian from the top business brass to simple road side sellers. There is reason behind this and that is because these guys rose from history of shit and were simple fishermen and all of sudden Toursimo dollars made them to forget their past. They are no difference than any ordinary Maldivian and they all have fishermen brains.
This is the reason why we support foreign investment; they come with money, education, ethics, rationality and brains. GMR would have been 100% better, Four Seasons. One and only, HPL Resorts Centara Grand and you name any foreign investor is testimony for this.
i like this part "..... Buruma would say, this is money I have worked hard to get this my money and you people are shit eating my money, Deen would say, I have done this and that for you and you are simply unthankful for my mercy. Koli would smell his finger after scratching his ass and would say, you “nagoo balhu “Bastard, when he gets fit when he meets his employees...."
Its actually very true.
why does MDP need this guy when he has no money?
The reporter was talking nonsense as it shows very clearly from the last part of the report that the management was paying their staff. Alidhoo is the main economic hub in the North and if it is closed there will have an economic disaster. I know Alidhoo still has more than 200 staffs and are still dealing with the local suppliers. So I salute for Mr.Jabir and hope that he will try his best to improve the business so then he will be able to pay his staff on time.